Seth Godin's Blog




Search

RSS Feeds






  • Subscribe with Viigo - for mobile
    [-for mobile]

SETH'S BOOKS

THE DIP BLOG by Seth Godin




All Marketers Are Liars Blog




Blog powered by TypePad
Member since 08/2003

« The Curse of Great Expectations | Main | Audiences are not a tool »

Are we all journalists?

So, there's now almost 3,000,000 bloggers tracked by some of the online services. That's 1% or so of the active online population, and since it seems as though the number is doubling every month or so, it's starting to get significant.

Remember how you used to curse journalists? Curse them for being lazy, or hyperbolic? How about this headline from today's Independent (UK newspaper):

"First Night: Clinton takes to the stage for the ultimate sell"

Ultimate? What makes it ultimate? A $30 book is hardly the ultimate sell, right?

But choosing words, choosing headlines, choosing photographs... it all adds up. When the New York Times admits that it colored its reporting the wrong way re Iraq, we're talking about a big side effect: thousands of people dead.

Now, everyone with a blog is a journalist. When you run a post accusing a politician of having no personality, for example, you're indulging the public's desire to elect a dinner partner, not a president. When you chime in on the day's talking points, you're a tool, not a new voice.

So, we come to the moment of truth. Now that anyone who wants to be a journalist CAN be a journalist, are the ethics going to get better... or worse?

I'm an optimist most of the time, but on this issue, I'm afraid I'm a realist.

Sigh.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/2123/802921

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Are we all journalists?:

» Blogging ethics from Johnnie Moore's Weblog
Seth Godin asks what happens to ethics when bloggers become journalists. I argue that transparency holds the key and suggest Seth might add comments to his blog! [Read More]

» Seth Says We're All Journalists from Micro Persuasion
Seth Godin wonders out loud: "Now that anyone who wants to be a journalist CAN be a journalist, are the ethics going to get better... or worse?" It's something PR pros should definitely ponder. We're entering a new world where [Read More]

» Are Bloggers Journalists? from WOLves
Seth wonders if we're all journalists. The short answer to that, as far as I'm concerned, is "Nope!" While I've done both reporting of actual news for my website in pre-blog days, and plenty of commentary as well as what [Read More]

» He Said, She Said, We Said from PressThink
That's what's being urged upon the press this year by some. But this is a different system of authority in political reporting, and it has consequences. If the press is now re-voicing itself for the Net era, that means a major shift. Once there was ... [Read More]

» Is blogging journalism or something else? from writelife
In reference to blogging, Seth asks "Are we all journalists?" My quick answer is no, though we all may be conversationalists trying to get our two cents in on a topic (l... [Read More]

» Seth Says We're All Journalists from unmediated
Seth Godin wonders out loud: "Now that anyone who wants to be a journalist CAN be a journalist, are the ethics going to get better... or worse?" It's something PR pros should definitely ponder. We're entering a new world where many personal journalists... [Read More]

» http://www.americandigest.org/sidelines/archives/001570.php from SideLines
Seth Godin's Schoolmarm Moment: "Now, everyone with a blog is a journalist. When you run a post accusing a politician of having no personality, for example, you're indulging the public's desire to elect a dinner partner, not a president. When you chime... [Read More]

» Ethics and Responsibility in Blogging from WillPate.org
Seth Godin asks a pertinent question about blogging ethics: So, we come to the moment of truth. Now that anyone who wants to be a journalist CAN be a journalist, are the ethics going to get better... or worse?Seth, it's... [Read More]

» http://publizistik-in-berlin.de/index.php?p=43 from Publizistik in Berlin
Seth Godin meint everyone with a blog is a journalist. [Read More]

» More on the topic of truth in blogs (and advertising) from Marketing Playbook
Seth's Blog: Are we all journalists? As per the Jefferson quote about advertising and newspapers/journalism, Seth Godin has sparked another really interesting discussion about objectivity, ethics and the choices we make when we write. Now we bloggers c... [Read More]

» The new water-cooler from "Hello_World"
I was reading Johnnie Moore's take on a recent post by Seth Godin on blogging as journalism. While I in principle agree with most of what he says here, I query one key-point. When there are millions of journalists, all [Read More]

» Three million bloggers? from Thoughtsignals
Seth Godin says there are three million "bloggers tracked by some of the online services." He doesn't give his sources, though. My questions: Three million bloggers or Three million blogs? How many of them are active (updated fairly recently and... [Read More]