Don't Miss a Thing
Free Updates by Email

Enter your email address

preview  |  powered by FeedBlitz

RSS Feeds

Share |

Facebook: Seth's Facebook
Twitter: @thisissethsblog






Seth Godin has written 18 bestsellers that have been translated into 35 languages

The complete list of online retailers

Bonus stuff!

or click on a title below to see the list


An intensive, 4-week online workshop designed to accelerate leaders to become change agents for the future. Designed by Seth Godin, for you.



All Marketers Tell Stories

Seth's most important book about the art of marketing




Free Prize Inside

The practical sequel to Purple Cow





An instant bestseller, the book that brings all of Seth's ideas together.




Meatball Sundae

Why the internet works (and doesn't) for your business. And vice versa.



Permission Marketing

The classic Named "Best Business Book" by Fortune.



Poke The Box

The latest book, Poke The Box is a call to action about the initiative you're taking - in your job or in your life, and Seth once again breaks the traditional publishing model by releasing it through The Domino Project.




Purple Cow

The worldwide bestseller. Essential reading about remarkable products and services.



Small is the New Big

A long book filled with short pieces from Fast Company and the blog. Guaranteed to make you think.



Survival is Not Enough

Seth's worst seller and personal favorite. Change. How it works (and doesn't).




The Big Moo

All for charity. Includes original work from Malcolm Gladwell, Tom Peters and Promise Phelon.



The Big Red Fez

Top 5 Amazon ebestseller for a year. All about web sites that work.




The Dip

A short book about quitting and being the best in the world. It's about life, not just marketing.




The Icarus Deception

Seth's most personal book, a look at the end of the industrial economy and what happens next.





"Book of the year," a perennial bestseller about leading, connecting and creating movements.




Unleashing the Ideavirus

More than 3,000,000 copies downloaded, perhaps the most important book to read about creating ideas that spread.



V Is For Vulnerable

A short, illustrated, kids-like book that takes the last chapter of Icarus and turns it into something worth sharing.




We Are All Weird

The end of mass and how you can succeed by delighting a niche.



Whatcha Gonna Do With That Duck?

The sequel to Small is the New Big. More than 600 pages of the best of Seth's blog.



THE DIP BLOG by Seth Godin

All Marketers Are Liars Blog

Blog powered by TypePad
Member since 08/2003

« PR and the first amendment and keeping your job | Main | Changing the game »

We accidentally marketed ourselves into a corner

What if I told you about an industry which:

  • Indebts most of its customers, sometimes for twenty or more years a person
  • Not only consumes most of four years of its customer's time, but impacts its prospects for years before even interacting with them
  • Enjoys extremely strong brand preferences between competitors and has virtually no successful generic substitutes
  • Dramatically alters relations within a family, often for generations
  • Doesn't do it on purpose


...according to most of the studies I've seen, there's very little or no difference in the efficacy of one competitor vs. another.

Of course, I'm talking about undergraduate colleges in the US.

The most competitive colleges are as competitive as ever--in most cases, more so. Many admit only one in ten students. According to two senior officials at Swarthmore, the differences among the 'good enough' applicants is basically zero. Rather than putting tens of thousands of kids through insane anxiety, they wonder, why not just put all the 'good enough' students in a pool and pick the winners randomly?

Here's the amazing part: According to The Chosen, an exhaustive study of college admissions, there's no measurable difference between the outcomes of education with the most exclusive schools and the next few tiers. Graduates don't end up happier. They don't end up with better paying jobs. They don't end up richer or even healthier.  The whole thing is a sham (which costs a quarter of a million dollars a person at the top end).

There's no question that a Harvard degree helps (or is even required) in a few fields. There's also no doubt that spending four years at Yale is a mind-changing experience. The question isn't, "are they wonderful?" The question is, "Is it worth it?"

It's almost as if every single high school student and her parents insisted on having a $200,000 stereo because it was better than the $1,000 stereo. Sure, it might be a bit better, but is it better enough?

Boomer parents have bought in to the marketing hype at a level rarely seen in any other form of marketing. They push school districts, teachers and their kids to perform pointless tasks at extreme levels just to be admitted to the 'right' school, even though there's hardly evidence that the right school does anything but boost their egos.

Schools respond by spending a fortune on facilities that will increase their rankings in various faux polls, even though there's no evidence at all that a better gym or a bigger library matters one bit to an undergraduate's long-term success in life.

If it weren't so expensive (in terms of time and money) it would make a marvelous marketing case study. Add in the tears and wasted anxiety and it's really a shame. Very few people are pointing out that the emperor is barely clothed, and those that do (like me, I guess) get yelled at.

I'm not criticizing a college education per se. No, it's clear that that's a smart investment. I'm talking about the incremental cost (and anxiety) separating consumers of the 'top' 500 schools from students of the 'top' 50. It appears to be pure storytelling, a story that so appeals to the worldview of baby boomers with teens that they are absolutely unable to resist the story, despite the facts.

High school students are thrust into a Dip, in some cases the biggest one of their lives. The Dip extracts significant costs along the way, and then ends with a giant spin of the roulette wheel. I wonder if we're marketing ourselves to a dead end.

I guess I'd do two things. First, I'd figure out how to teach parents to understand what really matters and what doesn't about time spent in high school and the choice of a college. Second, I'd push for every selective college to share one application and do a draft similar to the one they do for medical residencies. Every applicant ranks the schools they'd like to attend, in order. Every school considers all the applications, grabs the students they'd love to have in priority order, puts the rest into the "good enough" pile and lets a computer sort em all out as pareto optimally as possible. At least kids will go into their twenties correctly blaming a computer instead of mistakenly blaming themselves.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference We accidentally marketed ourselves into a corner:

» Why college admissions is a lot like starting a business from
Let me share an interesting conversation I had. A buddy and I were talking about a speaker he saw in an entrepreneurship class. The guy was from one of those search marekting firms, and it was clear he was there [Read More]

» College Admissions all Marketing? from Daeil Overseas Studies Program (DOSP)
To become great, you must surround yourself with great people. Seth Godin, is an incredible author and very wise in my mind. He sheds some light in my industry, Secondary and Post-Secondary Education. I completely agree with him Read the whole a... [Read More]

» The Undergrad Racket from A Beginning Teacher
I think I grew up in the first generation that assumed I would be going to college, and the question was "where," not "if." (Of course, no one bothered to ask me "what," which would have been helpful!) Seth Godin points out that the generation after ... [Read More]

» i could never say this from ideas for conversations
because no one would listen to me. But I can agree wholeheartedly. ... [Read More]

» A Proposition for Marines from The Art of the 3 Disciplines
Seth Godin wrote an interesting article about the value of going to a big name school versus a lesser-name school that set my gears in motion. In it he writes: Theres no question that a Harvard degree helps (or is even required) in a few field... [Read More]

» Chicago GSB Named #1 MBA by Business Week - 10 Metrics to Redesign from David Dalka - Creating Revenue and Retention - Chicago GSB MBA
The University of Chicago Graduate School of Business (Chicago GSB) was rated the top MBA program in the Business Week bi-annual MBA survey of recruiters and students. As a proud alumni, I want be clear that I appreciate the quality students, alumni an... [Read More]

» Seth Godin Keynoting Search Engine Strategies Chicago and His New Book Meatball Sundae from David Dalka - Creating Revenue and Retention - Chicago GSB MBA
In advance his upcoming speech at Search Engine Strategies Chicago, Seth Godin held a intimate conference call in regards to the conference and his upcoming book Meatball Sundae. At first I was thinking this would be a long speech, it was in actuality ... [Read More]

» Sound-Off Friday: Higher Education from ValueAverager - Official Blog
Seth Godin, the brilliant marketer, recently wrote about how elite universities are way too costly. Not only is the tuition extraordinarily high, but the amount of grade-grubbing and resume-polishing that is required in order to get accepted is enormou... [Read More]

» Good Law Schools Make For Bad Marketers from Business Development
Seth Godin posted something yesterday I've been chewing on. His point is that elite colleges are a marketing creation and something of a scam. I think the same thing, slightly altered, is true of law schools. Good law schools make [Read More]

» Is Harvard worth it? from Through the Keyhole
Heres an excerpt from Seth Godins marketing view of elite colleges and universities: According to The Chosen, an exhaustive study of college admissions, there's no measurable difference between the outcomes of education with the most exclusive schools ... [Read More]

» Education as an Investment from Jesse Luna
An investment is only as good as the goals you set for it. Marketing guru Seth Godin recently posted a blog entry on the value of elite education. While I can see many of his points - it indebts families, [Read More]

« PR and the first amendment and keeping your job | Main | Changing the game »